Not a committee of experts
The choice of the Twelve is itself a statement. In an age that prized learning and status, Jesus assembled a working crew — several fishermen, a despised tax collector, a zealot who'd wanted Rome overthrown — and made them the foundation. The Gospels don't tidy them up, either. They argue about rank, miss the point of parables, fall asleep at the worst moment, and scatter when the danger comes.
That candor is part of why the story carries the weight it does. Peter, the leader, denies even knowing Jesus three times on the night of the arrest. Thomas refuses to believe the resurrection until he can touch the wounds. Judas Iscariot betrays him outright. These aren't airbrushed saints; they're recognizable people who failed and, in most of the accounts, were restored. The claim Christianity makes is not that the apostles were remarkable, but that something worked through unremarkable men — and that the movement's survival is hard to explain by their talents alone.